Home

A guide to homeowners insurance for older or historic homes

Kate MacDougall Senior Risk Consultant & Historic Home Specialist, Chubb Personal Risk Services
office with a library in a historical home

Older and historic homes carry a charm and character that newer construction simply cannot replicate. Homeowners should consider their home’s specific needs and make sure those needs are met through the right insurance coverage. Aging systems, rare materials, and preservation requirements all affect how your home is valued and covered.

Homeowners should review standard home insurance policies to ensure they include coverage options that benefit an older property. This guide explains what makes these homes unique, what to look for in a policy, and how to protect your investment.

Learn more about homeowners insurance

Why insurance for historic homes is unique

Many owners of historic properties view themselves as stewards of history rather than just owners. Because of this, having a policy that allows you to restore, not just rebuild, is vital. When reviewing a policy, pay close attention to:

  • Coverage caps — Ensure there are no restrictive limits on total payouts.
  • Material quality — Check if you are allowed to replace damaged areas with "like kind and quality" materials.
  • Code updates — Confirm if the policy covers the cost of bringing the home up to modern building standards if a covered loss occurs.
  • Choice of professional — Determine if you can choose your own contractor, architect, or engineer.

7 ways older homes are different

Older properties come with unique risks and needs that may vary from newer homes. Here are seven factors that may set them apart should the home need to be restored or rebuilt:

  1. Outdated electrical and plumbing — Systems like knob and tube wiring, lead pipes, or asbestos insulation may need to be replaced or removed to meet safety standards.
  2. Hard to source materials — Restoring antique flooring, plaster moldings, custom width millwork, or antique window glass can cost significantly more than using modern alternatives.
  3. Code upgrade costs — Repairs often trigger requirements for modern safety features, such as egress windows, specific staircase railing heights, or new fire blocking and insulation.
  4. Historic district compliance — If your home is in a historic district, an architectural review board may require you to replicate original windows, brickwork, or roofing materials exactly.
  5. Valuables and antiques — Historic homes are often furnished with period appropriate light fixtures and furniture. These items may need their own specialized coverage to avoid exceeding your standard contents limit.
  6. Unique roofs — Older homes often feature decorative slate, hand crimped copper, standing seam metal, turrets, or decorative chimneys that require specialized repair skills.
  7. Specialized craftspeople — Finding qualified contractors and craftspeople who understand and are experienced in historic materials is one of the most difficult parts of owning an older home.

Why older or historic homes may cost more to insure

Generally, insurance for older or historic homes is more expensive because of three main factors: time, quality, and experience.

Finding or salvaging older building materials can be a lengthy process. Materials of like kind and quality, which were once standard, can now be costly and difficult to find. Additionally, skilled craftspeople who can work with these materials are in short supply and high demand. All of these factors contribute to the higher cost of restoring an older home after a loss.

Learn what to consider before buying a historic home

Understanding an HO-8 insurance policy

An HO-8 policy is a homeowners insurance policy designed for older or historic homes with hard-to-replace features.

Homeowners should carefully consider the differences between an HO-8 and a standard HO-3 policy to determine which coverage best fits their home’s age, unique features, and insurance needs. Because each home can vary, it is highly recommended that you work with a trusted insurance agent to determine which option is the best fit for your home.

Don't forget outbuildings

A historic property may also include historically significant outbuildings that require protection. This includes structures such as:

  • Barns and stables
  • Spring houses and ice houses
  • Summer kitchens or smoke houses
     

Ensure your policy provides adequate coverage limits for these additional structures so they can be restored alongside the main house.

Additional coverages to consider

Coverage What It Covers

Guaranteed replacement cost

Covers the full cost to rebuild your home even if it exceeds your policy limit

Scheduled personal property

Provides broader coverage for high value items like antiques and artwork

Water backup coverage

Covers damage from backed up drains or sump pump failure — a common risk in older plumbing

Additional living expenses

Covers living expenses in comparable temporary housing if your home is uninhabitable during a lengthy restoration

Get professional guidance on insuring your older home

Insuring an older or historic home takes more than a standard approach. An independent insurance agent can help you navigate policy options and help build a plan that protects the historical integrity of your property.

Insights and expertise

We help you stay ahead and informed with these helpful tips and tricks for protecting your home, car, and more.
luxury kitchen

Vacant but protected: Tips for safeguarding vacant homes

Key actions can help protect your empty home from damage and break-ins.
broken tree and stop sign

Protect your home from wind and wind-driven rain

Windstorms such as hurricanes and tropical storms can damage homes in any coastal location on the U.S. Atlantic and Gulf coasts. Find out how homeowners can safeguard their homes from windstorms.
flood on street

Protecting your family and home from a flood

Flood damage can be mitigated if you and your family take precautionary measures. Here are some steps you can take before, during and after a flood.
father playing guitar with his daughter

Top 6 ways to make your home more energy efficient

To save money and improve your home’s energy efficiency, you’ll want to start with its outer shell – the walls, windows and doors – then move to the inside spaces.

Get a personal insurance quote

Work with an independent agent to get personalized insurance solutions.